Understanding Nutrition
By Ellie Whitney, Sharon Rady Rolfes
Publisher: Wadsworth Publishing
Number Of Pages: 720
Publication Date: 2007-04-30
ISBN-10 / ASIN: 0495116696
ISBN-13 / EAN: 9780495116691
Product Description:
This is the most widely used introductory nutrition text used by students from around the world and you will see that it's a text worth keeping! Not only will this best-selling book help you excel in your nutrition course, Whitney and Rolfes' UNDERSTANDING NUTRITION will also guide you in applying the most current nutrition research and show the relevance to your own life. UNDERSTANDING NUTRITION is at the forefront of the latest advances in human nutrition-helping you understand what the scientific facts tell us about human nutrition and health. Ellie Whitney and Sharon Rady Rolfes begin with the basics-an introduction to the nutrients;and then guide you through every important topic covered in today's nutrition courses. Linked chapter by chapter to the CengageNOW, a new online resource that provides you with PERSONALIZED STUDY tools, Thomson Audio Study Products, animations that clarify complex processes, and much more, this Eleventh Edition of UNDERSTANDING NUTRITION features everything you need to keep on top of this quickly evolving field.
Summary: Understanding nutrition.
Rating: 4
When I bought this book, I thought that I would get the book bundled with a CD that gives access to online resources related to the subject (This is the standard for this book). I informed the customer service that there was no CD with the book but unfortunately the book they send me again comes with no CD. My sister (the end user of the book) was forced to pay additional money to get online access. I was a bit disappointed about it.However, I also want to congratulate the seller on their politeness and speed in shipping the stuff.I am always content with the service I get through Amazon and I hope I will continue to be a client.
Summary: Nutrition
Rating: 2
It's a good book with lots of good infromation. Too bad the class will stop using it after this semester
Summary: Understanding Nutrition
Rating: 3
* Overall good
** DOES NOT include appendices that I needed for several assignments!!
*** Would like to be able to type in a key word or page number and be able to go directly to it.
Summary: Misunderstanding Nutrition
Rating: 1
My comments are on the 10th ed., 2005. With over a million sold this book is a major influence on diet, dieticians and nutritionists. The authors assure that it is based on the best science available, and that only a Registered Dietician (RD) can be relied on for accurate information. An RD can be obtained by achieving a 4-year degree in a related subject, then passing an examination given by the American Dietetic Association. Coverage is intended to be comprehensive, and it could have been on 990 big pages. The writing is very clear, but contains internal inconsistencies. Many citations appear to support the authors' (and ADA's) positions. Kilocalories (kcal) are correctly used instead of calories. Advice is given for the "average" American for whom the authors made tiny changes in intakes of many nutrients based on age, sex, and pregnancy, but none for metabolic types, such as low-carbohydrate diets for people prone to diabetes, or most types of food allergies.
But there is a serious omission of celiac and Crohn's diseases and their causes, which are grain, gluten, and gliadin allergies which also lead to several types of cancers. This must be related to the authors' incessant promotion of whole grain foods and carbohydrates in general despite 10-50% of Americans suffering from grain allergies. Irritable bowel syndrome is mentioned with high-fat intake as the supposed cause, when grains, intestinal flora and stress are more likely.
While "balanced diets" are lauded, the actual diets recommended are high carbohydrate (300 g/day, 60% of energy intake), tempered only to 50% for diabetics despite extensive un-cited findings that serum glucose control, hyper- and hypoglycemia are uncontrollable with such diets. Type-2 diabetes is preventable and treatable with low-carb, high-fat diets, which are anathema to these authors.
One reason is fear of fat, especially animal fat, as supposedly atherogenic, one of the most pervasive messages in this book, ignoring observations in groups such as the Inuit, Masai, and long-term (up to 50 years) use of high-animal fat diets by physicians. The Spanish Paradox (among others) was the result of observations that between 1964 and 1991, per capita bread consumption fell by 55%, rice by 35%, and potato by 53%. During this period beef and full-cream milk consumption doubled, poultry tripled and pork intake quadrupled. During this period heart disease deaths fell by 25% in men and 34% in women; blood pressures and stroke deaths dropped. Spanish now live 2 years longer than Americans. Between 1959 and 2004, there were at least 50 articles by researchers seeking to prove a connection between fat intake or cholesterol levels and "heart disease" (CVD) where none found a positive correlation.
Among chemistry errors was the claim that loss of an electron by a stable molecule gave a free radical, implicated in atherogenicity and carcinogenicity (p389). Such a loss of a negative charge would lead to formation of a positive and negative ion pair, not a free radical, which is commonly formed when a hydrogen atom with its electron is removed. This is exactly the reason that polyunsaturated fats are more likely to form free radicals (and go rancid) than saturated or monounsaturated fats, making them less desirable. Ignored was a well-done study that pitted animal fat against olive and corn oils. After two years there were the following percentages of subjects free from major cardiac events: animal fat 75%, olive oil 57% and corn oil 52%.
Cholesterol was such a bugaboo to Whitney and Rolfes that they admitted not a single direct function of it in the body! Cell and organelle membranes were drawn with no cholesterol present, where in fact, it is essential as it also is in nerve synapses and other brain function. Low cholesterol levels' association with cancer, depression, violence, and all-cause mortality were missing. A search of citations such as these authors used was made by Uffe Ravnskov, MD, PhD, to find the original studies or trials supporting a deadly role for dietary saturated fat or cholesterol without success. The earlier sources had no or opposite evidence to support their claims. Whitney and Rolfes even touted the Seven Countries Study of Ancel Keys, M.D. (p174), long exposed as a fraud utilizing data suppression. In addition, they quoted an NCEP/NHLBI/AHA publication that claimed a 1% reduction of serum cholesterol level gave a 2% reduction in CVD (p176); but a concurrent publication and many other studies showed the opposite. In the elderly, those with the higher cholesterol levels live the longest, as do those whose cholesterol levels do not drop on their own.
Dietary fiber was strongly recommended to prevent both CVD and colon cancer, despite an admission that the research was contradictory (p124). A 16-year study on 89,000 women and a meta-analysis of 17 studies showed no effect on CVD and 35-50% increases in colon cancer.
Whitney and Rolfes even touted choosing wild fish over farmed fish, writing that the wild fish contained more omega-3 fats, exactly opposite of a recent study's findings.
Salt limitation to 6 g/day "to lower blood pressure" was presented despite the very persuasive evidence showing that BP will go down in only 1/5 of people, that it will go up in 1/5, and that 3/5 will be almost unaffected by changing salt intake. Overall, in the gigantic Intersalt trial, there was little effect of salt on BP, while greater potassium intake was hypotensive. In 2003, the Cochrane Collaboration agreed.
Best single volume nutrition book I know of: Groves B. Trick and Treat: How "Healthy Eating" is Making Us Ill. London, England: Hammersmith Press, 2008. Not a textbook. See my Amazon review.
a little intense. Once again fantastic delivery time
Rich (BB code):
http://ifile.it/lmeai47/understanding_nutrition__11th_edition_.part1.rar
http://ifile.it/3a8hvw4/understanding_nutrition__11th_edition_.part2.rar
http://ifile.it/7wqpzru/understanding_nutrition__11th_edition_.part3.rar